6 min readUpdated

Acne Scar Types and Microneedling: Rolling, Boxcar and Ice Pick Explained

How rolling, boxcar and ice pick acne scars differ, which ones respond to microneedling, why ice pick scars usually need another approach, and what the SkinPen trial found.

Comparison of rolling, boxcar and ice-pick acne scars on a man’s cheeks.

In a hurry? Skim mode fades everything except the highlighted takeaways.

If you only read one thing

Rolling scars and shallow boxcar scars respond most to microneedling, because they are broad, fairly shallow depressions that new collagen can lift. Deep boxcar scars respond less, and ice pick scars, which are under 2 mm wide and run deep, usually need punch excision or TCA CROSS. In the SkinPen FDA trial, 55% of patients had their scars graded better six months after three sessions.

  • Acne scars are classified as rolling, boxcar or ice pick (Jacob, Dover and Kaminer, JAAD 2001).
  • Rolling and shallow boxcar scars respond most to microneedling; ice pick scars respond least.
  • In the SkinPen FDA trial, blinded dermatologists graded 55% of patients improved six months after three sessions, and none got worse.
  • Ice pick scars usually need punch excision or TCA CROSS, and active acne must be controlled before microneedling.
  • Microneedling at KORA: $350 per session, or $450 with PRF.
On this page 6 sections
  1. The three types of acne scars
  2. Which acne scars respond to microneedling
  3. Why ice pick scars usually need a different approach
  4. Before you start: active acne comes first
  5. A realistic acne scar plan at KORA
  6. Frequently asked questions

The three main acne scar types, rolling, boxcar and ice pick, do not respond to microneedling equally. In this guide I explain how dermatologists classify acne scars, which types microneedling helps most, why ice pick scars usually need a different tool, what the FDA trial behind SkinPen found, and what a realistic scar plan looks like.

3 typesice pick, rolling and boxcar, in the classification most clinicians use (JAAD, 2001)
55%of SkinPen trial patients had scars graded better by blinded dermatologists six months after 3 sessions
90%of those patients said their scars had improved

The three types of acne scars

Most depressed acne scars fall into one of three shapes, and the shape decides the treatment. The classification comes from a 2001 paper in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology by dermatologists Carolyn Jacob, Jeffrey Dover and Michael Kaminer, and it is still the one most clinicians use.

TypeWhat it looks likeSizeFirst-line treatment in the 2001 paperMicroneedling
RollingBroad, shallow dips that give the skin a wavy surface, caused by bands tethering the skin to the tissue belowUsually wider than 4 to 5 mmSubcisionGood response
BoxcarRound or oval dips with sharp, vertical edges, like a small crater1.5 to 4 mm across; shallow ones 0.1 to 0.5 mm deepShallow: laser resurfacing. Deep: punch techniquesShallow ones respond well; deep ones less
Ice pickNarrow, deep tracts that look like an enlarged poreUnder 2 mm wide, reaching the deep dermisPunch excisionLimited on its own

Most people with acne scarring have a mix. What matters for planning is which type is dominant and in which areas.

Which acne scars respond to microneedling

Rolling scars and shallow boxcar scars respond most to microneedling; ice pick scars respond least. Microneedling works by triggering new collagen in the upper and middle layers of the skin, which lifts and softens broad, shallow depressions. A narrow scar that runs deep into the dermis is largely out of its reach.

Research matches that order. In a 2023 split-face study in Dermatologic Surgery, Krishnegowda, Pradhan and Belgaumkar treated 40 patients with four monthly sessions of microneedling plus injectable platelet-rich fibrin (PRF) on one side of the face and microneedling plus saline on the other. Rolling scars responded best, followed by boxcar and then ice pick scars. On the PRF side, the average Goodman and Baron scar grade fell from 3.45 to 1.47 at 24 weeks.

What the SkinPen FDA trial found

SkinPen, the device we use, was authorized by the FDA in 2018 to improve the appearance of facial acne scars in adults 22 and older. In the trial summarized in the FDA’s De Novo review, 20 patients had three sessions 30 days apart. Six months after the last session, blinded dermatologists graded 55 percent as improved and 45 percent as unchanged; none got worse. Ninety percent of the patients rated their own scars as improved, and 90 percent said they would recommend the treatment. The trial included skin types II through VI, and there were no serious adverse events.

Those numbers set fair expectations: most people see a real change over a series, a meaningful minority see less than they hoped, and the change is gradual. The American Academy of Dermatology describes 3 to 5 treatments, 2 to 4 weeks apart, and says studies show this can fade acne scars by 50 to 70 percent.

Why ice pick scars usually need a different approach

Ice pick scars are too narrow and too deep for microneedling alone to fill. The 2001 JAAD paper recommends punch excision, where the scar is cut out with a tiny round blade and closed. Another option is TCA CROSS, in which a high-strength trichloroacetic acid (70 to 100 percent) is placed inside each scar to stimulate collagen from within. DermNet, the New Zealand dermatology reference, describes a typical course of 3 to 6 treatments with a one to two grade improvement over six months, and notes that complete resolution with TCA CROSS alone is unlikely and that pigment changes are a risk.

If your scarring is mainly ice pick, microneedling is not the right main tool: ice pick and deep boxcar scars usually need other techniques such as punch excision or TCA CROSS, and the consultation will tell you whether microneedling is the right tool for your scars. When ice pick scars sit alongside rolling and boxcar scars, microneedling can still treat the broader areas while the ice pick scars are handled separately.

Before you start: active acne comes first

Microneedling treats old scars, not active breakouts, so acne needs to be under control first. The SkinPen trial excluded anyone with more than five inflammatory lesions in a treatment area, and anyone who had taken isotretinoin in the previous six months. The AAD advises postponing microneedling if you have painful, deep or pus-filled pimples, and waiting at least one month after the last isotretinoin dose. If you are still breaking out, a sensible order is to start with skin care or a VI Peel and move to microneedling once the skin is calm.

A realistic acne scar plan at KORA

For mostly rolling and shallow boxcar scarring, 4 to 6 microneedling sessions spaced 4 to 6 weeks apart is typical. Photos taken in the same light before each session make progress easier to compare. Results keep building for months after the last session, so the outcome is judged at the end of the series. Microneedling can also be done with PRF; I compare PRF and PRP in PRF vs PRP for microneedling.

SkinPen microneedling

Per session$350

Microneedling with PRF

Per session$450

Consultation

Scar assessmentComplimentary

Prices come from our current price list. Your plan and total are confirmed at a complimentary consultation before anything begins.

Learn more about SkinPen PRF microneedling, and read our microneedling aftercare guide before your first session. Our clinic is on the Scottsdale and Paradise Valley border.

SkinPen PRF MicroneedlingSkinPen microneedling in Scottsdale at KORA Aesthetics — $350 alone or $450 with PRF drawn from your own blood. Acne scarring, texture, enlarged pores and early lines, treated by a nurse practitioner. See how many sessions it takes, what the PRF upgrade actually adds, and the day-by-day recovery.See treatment, prices and results
Share this articleEmail

Frequently asked questions

What type of acne scars does microneedling work best on?

Rolling scars and shallow boxcar scars. They are broad and fairly shallow, so the new collagen microneedling triggers can lift them.

Does microneedling work on ice pick scars?

Only a little on its own. Ice pick scars are under 2 mm wide and run deep, so punch excision or TCA CROSS usually works better, sometimes combined with microneedling for surrounding scars.

How do I know what type of acne scars I have?

Rolling scars look wavy and soften when the skin is stretched, boxcar scars have sharp edges that stay visible, and ice pick scars look like deep, narrow pores. Most people have a mix, so an in-person assessment with side lighting is the most reliable way to tell.

How many microneedling sessions do acne scars need?

Usually 4 to 6 sessions spaced 4 to 6 weeks apart. The AAD describes 3 to 5 treatments for acne scars, and the SkinPen FDA trial used three.

How much improvement can I expect from microneedling for acne scars?

In the SkinPen FDA trial, 55% of patients were graded improved by blinded dermatologists and 90% reported improvement themselves. The AAD cites studies showing 50 to 70% fading after a series.

Is microneedling safe for darker skin with acne scars?

The SkinPen FDA trial included skin types II to VI and reported no serious adverse events. Careful depth choices and strict sun protection lower the risk of pigment changes.

How much does microneedling for acne scars cost?

SkinPen microneedling at KORA is $350 per session, or $450 with PRF. The scar assessment is complimentary.

Sources

  1. Jacob CI, Dover JS, Kaminer MS. Acne scarring: a classification system and review of treatment options. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 2001;45:109-117
  2. US Food and Drug Administration. De Novo classification request for SkinPen Precision System (DEN160029), decision summary
  3. Krishnegowda R, Pradhan SN, Belgaumkar VA. A split-face study to evaluate efficacy of autologous injectable platelet-rich fibrin with microneedling against microneedling with normal saline in atrophic acne scars. Dermatologic Surgery, 2023
  4. Logan I, Elghblawi E, Oakley A. TCA CROSS. DermNet, 2018
  5. American Academy of Dermatology. Microneedling can fade scars, uneven skin tone, and more. AAD.org, 2023

Katie Manhardt

Founder & Nurse Practitioner · MSN, FNP-C

Board-certified family nurse practitioner and founder of KORA Aesthetics in Scottsdale. Katie is a national clinical trainer for Galderma and Prollenium — selected to teach injection technique and facial anatomy to other medical professionals. Every treatment at KORA is performed by Katie or by one…

Read the full profile